American Samoa's gun ban exposes a Second Amendment gap, Davis argues
There's a U.S. territory where the Second Amendment reportedly doesn't exist on paper, and almost nobody noticed when its top court made that call last year.
Snapshot
Mike Davis, founder of the Article III Project, writes in a Fox News opinion piece that the High Court of American Samoa ruled in October 2024 that the Second Amendment does not apply in the unincorporated territory, clearing the way for a near-total gun ban. Davis argues President Trump and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum have the legal authority to reverse the ruling and should use it.
Key points
- The ruling: According to Davis, American Samoa's High Court decided the territory's unincorporated status means the Second Amendment doesn't apply, letting a near-total gun ban stand.
- Unusual setup: Davis notes American Samoa has no federal court and no birthright citizenship statute, unlike other U.S. territories, with its High Court justices appointed and removable by the Interior Secretary rather than confirmed by the Senate.
- The fix, as Davis sees it: He points to 48 U.S.C. § 1661, which he says gives the president civil, military and judicial control over American Samoa, authority he argues Trump and Burgum could use to overrule the decision without a lawsuit.
- Context: Davis ties this to the Supreme Court's recent Wolford v. Lopez decision striking down Hawaii's restrictive concealed-carry rules, which he calls proof the Second Amendment applies equally across states and territories.
Quick take
This one's worth a read if you follow Second Amendment law past the usual state-by-state fights. Davis is making a legal argument, not reporting a settled fact, so take his call for executive action as his opinion on what should happen next. Still, a U.S. territory with an effective gun ban and no federal court to challenge it in is the kind of wrinkle most gun owners have never heard about.
Read the full story: foxnews.com